Shelter Island Used Cars for Sale by Owner

Finding and buying a used car from private owner in Shelter Island is easy and could save you a lot on your next car purchase. Sell your car online, it's FREE!

11 Cars for Sale by Owner in Shelter Island

Showing 1 - 11 of 11 Listings
Sort By
  • Blue 1995 Mercedes-Benz E-Class
    14
    $6,200
    Price
    67,000 Mi
    7
    Score
    Poor Deal
    Color: Blue
    Save
    Private Seller Anthony
    East Hampton, NY 11937
    9.33 Miles Away
  • White 1962 Chevrolet Corvair
    3
    $15,000
    Price
    82,000 Mi
    Color: White
    Save
    Private Seller Anthony
    East Hampton, NY 11937
    9.33 Miles Away
  • Silver 2014 Mercedes-Benz E-Class
    19
    $16,500
    Price
    106,890 Mi
    66
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color: Silver
    Save
    Private Seller Sylvester
    Clinton, CT 06413
    18.52 Miles Away
  • White 2012 Chevrolet Impala Limited
    5
    $8,750
    Price
    149,600 Mi
    54
    Score
    Good Deal
    Color: White
    • Cheap Car
    Save

    Owner Says: New Tires and Brakes, Fluids, Radiator, Thermostat, All Filters,Tire air sensors any any thing else you can think of. Interior looks new. Vehicle is perfect.

    Private Seller Kenneth
    Riverhead, NY 11901
    19.22 Miles Away
  • Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    $2,200
    Price
    280 Mi
    Color: Blue
    • Car Under $5,000
    Save
    Private Seller Robert
    New London, CT 06320
    22.97 Miles Away
  • Blue 2010 Toyota Prius
    6
    $4,999
    Price
    279,000 Mi
    47
    Score
    Good Deal
    Color: Blue
    • Car Under $5,000
    Save

    Owner Says: I've been the only driver since new. This was my company car and has been driven all highway miles. Only the driver's seat was ever used, and it's never been in an accident. I just replaced the 12V ...more

    Private Seller Robert
    Westhampton, NY 11977
    24.28 Miles Away
  • Gray 2019 Ford F-150 Supercrew
    15
    $41,000
    Price
    42,900 Mi
    Color: Gray
    Save

    Owner Says: -XLT Series / Rear Window Defroster / Sirius Radio / Remote Start / XLT Chrome Appearance Package / Chrome Step Bars / 3.5L V6 Ecoboost / 275/55R20 Tires / 20" Chrome-like PVD Wheels / 3.31 Axle / ...more

    Private Seller Tony
    Calverton, NY 11933
    24.35 Miles Away
  • Red 2004 Toyota Tacoma
    3
    $18,000
    Price
    71,600 Mi
    56
    Score
    Good Deal
    Color: Red
    • Low Miles
    Save

    Owner Says: Very clean and low mileage TRD Tacoma SR5 XtraCab. New Calipers/Rotors Pads front and New Drums/Shoes rear. Frame replaced by Toyota after recall. These trucks in this condition are in high demand ...more

    Private Seller Howard
    Groton, CT 06340
    24.91 Miles Away
  • Blue 2012 Honda Civic
    6
    $11,995
    Price
    98,000 Mi
    37
    Score
    Fair Deal
    Color: Blue
    • Low Miles
    Save

    Owner Says: Drives and shifts like new clean no accidents dents or rust garaged serviced regularly and was owned by my Dad who took special care of his car. Low low miles and asking $11,995.(860)949-8065

    Private Seller Robert
    Groton, CT 06340
    24.91 Miles Away
  • Red 2005 Chrysler Crossfire
    8
    $12,000
    Price
    22,000 Mi
    76
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color: Red
    Save

    Owner Says: Kept garaged when not driving. Comes with a Thornton chip package which plugs into the computer port. Run with or without, your choice. Added new Vredestein tires all around within the last 6 ...more

    Private Seller Greg
    Manorville, NY 11949
    27.90 Miles Away
  • Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    $3,850
    Price
    102 Mi
    100
    Score
    Best Deal
    Color: Green
    • Cheap Car
    Save

    Owner Says: Second owner. Runs great. Always garaged.

    Private Seller Jim
    Branford, CT 06405
    28.01 Miles Away