Share

Shelter Island Used Cars for Sale by Owner

Finding and buying a used car from private owner in Shelter Island is easy and could save you a lot on your next car purchase. Sell you car online, it's FREE!

48 Cars for Sale by Owner in Shelter Island

Showing 1 - 20 of 48 Listings
Sort By
  • 75,668
    Mileage
    $3,500
    Price
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    car photo
    5
    Save
    42
    Score
    Good Deal
    Color - White
    Private Seller Shelter Island Bo
  • 104,143
    Mileage
    $11,995
    Price
    Southold, NY 11971
    4.15 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    60
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color - White
    Owner Says:

    This Volvo is in excellent condition inside and out. All scheduled maintenance done professionally with records

    Private Seller John Hiney
  • 17,000
    Mileage
    $8,500
    Price
    Southold, NY 11971
    4.15 Miles Away
    car photo
    6
    Save
    Color - Silver
    Private Seller Michael Jackowski
  • 16,000
    Mileage
    $60,000
    Price
    East Hampton, NY 11937
    9.33 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    89
    Score
    Best Deal
    Color - Silver
    Private Seller Daniel Hilpert
  • 137,000
    Mileage
    $25,000
    Price
    East Hampton, NY 11937
    9.33 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    Color - Black
    Owner Says:

    Original owner. Never been in an accident. Excellent

    Private Seller Barry Marcus
  • 37,000
    Mileage
    $16,850
    Price
    East Hampton, NY 11937
    9.33 Miles Away
    car photo
    Save
    Color - Green
    Owner Says:

    2014 Mini Countryman in Oxford Metallic Green, purchased in January 2014, in mint condition. Under 40k in mileage.

    Private Seller Hannah Selinger
  • 75,730
    Mileage
    $7,444
    Price
    Drop $551
    Aquebogue, NY 11931
    15.99 Miles Away
    car photo
    4
    Save
    100
    Score
    Best Deal
    Color - Black
    Private Seller Rosina Comunale
  • 33,800
    Mileage
    $24,600
    Price
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    16.31 Miles Away
    car photo
    5
    Save
    70
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color - Black
    Private Seller Elliot
  • 120,500
    Mileage
    $2,750
    Price
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    16.31 Miles Away
    car photo
    10
    Save
    70
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color - White
    Owner Says:

    Starts and runs. Everything works. CT clean title. Has some parking lot type dings an a tear on the rear bumper

    Private Seller William Dunn
  • 75,000
    Mileage
    $3,500
    Price
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    16.31 Miles Away
    car photo
    11
    Save
    Color - Other
    Private Seller Peggy millspaugh
  • 93,000
    Mileage
    $7,000
    Price
    Niantic, CT 06357
    18.71 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    100
    Score
    Best Deal
    Color - Silver
    Private Seller Hugh Hunsinger
  • 80,150
    Mileage
    $11,000
    Price
    Riverhead, NY 11901
    19.22 Miles Away
    car photo
    3
    Save
    100
    Score
    Best Deal
    Color - White
    Owner Says:

    4-Cyl GDI 2.4 Liter,Automatic 6-Spd w/Overdrive & FWD,Traction Control,Stability Control,ABS (4-Wheel),Keyless

    Private Seller Dorothy Ferrentino
  • 136,000
    Mileage
    $3,000
    Price
    Riverhead, NY 11901
    19.22 Miles Away
    car photo
    7
    Save
    Color - Silver
    Private Seller Jack
  • 35,000
    Mileage
    $48,000
    Price
    East Lyme, CT 06333
    21.86 Miles Away
    car photo
    5
    Save
    Color - Black
    Owner Says:

    1955 Buick Special Resto-Mod. Fresh build with too much to list. Rotisserie frame off with the best of everything.

    Private Seller Mark Vaughan
  • 34,000
    Mileage
    $23,950
    Price
    Drop $5,045
    Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
    23.90 Miles Away
    car photo
    12
    Save
    Color - Red
    Owner Says:

    390 Big Block Engine w/ 34 k miles on rebuild. Just completed major mechanical inspection & replacement of parts.

    Private Seller Blade Marketing
  • 134,000
    Mileage
    $8,900
    Price
    KILLINGWORTH, CT 06419
    24.83 Miles Away
    car photo
    10
    Save
    82
    Score
    Best Deal
    Color - Gray
    Owner Says:

    Exceptionally clean, drives like new, highway miles, heated seats, remote start, has to be seen to

    Private Seller Conrad
  • 133,000
    Mileage
    $4,000
    Price
    Drop $2,000
    Manorville, NY 11949
    27.90 Miles Away
    car photo
    5
    Save
    Color - Blue
    Private Seller Harry Langhorn
  • 220,000
    Mileage
    $3,000
    Price
    Branford, CT 06405
    28.01 Miles Away
    car photo
    2
    Save
    78
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color - Blue
    Private Seller Elisha Teague
  • 26,000
    Mileage
    $20,000
    Price
    Branford, CT 06405
    28.01 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    Color - Silver
    Owner Says:

    One owner. Very well maintained and very clean. Brand new tires.

    Private Seller Paul
  • 121,000
    Mileage
    $2,000
    Price
    Branford, CT 06405
    28.01 Miles Away
    car photo
    Save
    Color - Black
    Private Seller Jennifer Thiste
Prev Page Page 1Next Page


Share Car Listings: