Share

Bay Shore Used Cars for Sale by Owner

Finding and buying a used car from private owner in Bay Shore is easy and could save you a lot on your next car purchase. Sell your car online, it's FREE!

72 Cars for Sale by Owner in Bay Shore

Showing 1 - 20 of 72 Listings
Sort By
  • 2015 Nissan Altima
    119,500
    Mileage
    $9,000
    Price
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    car photo
    6
    Save
    74
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color: Black
    Private Seller Deanna
  • 1992 Ford F-450 Super Duty
    87,000
    Mileage
    $12,500
    Price
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    car photo
    6
    Save
    Color: White
    Owner Says:

    1992 Super Duty gooseneck Flatbed Pick Up. New tires. Excellent work truck.

    Private Seller Mark
  • 2000 Ford F-550
    142,156
    Mileage
    $14,000
    Price
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    car photo
    3
    Save
    Color: White
    Private Seller Tammy
  • 2012 Acura TL
    80,000
    Mileage
    $15,995
    Price
    East Islip, NY 11730
    6.42 Miles Away
    car photo
    8
    Save
    Color: Black
    Private Seller Jamie
  • 2010 Nissan Xterra
    172,000
    Mileage
    $5,995
    Price
    East Islip, NY 11730
    6.42 Miles Away
    car photo
    6
    Save
    Color: Silver
    Private Seller Jamie
  • 2006 Toyota Tacoma
    129,000
    Mileage
    $9,995
    Price
    East Islip, NY 11730
    6.42 Miles Away
    car photo
    8
    Save
    Color: Silver
    Private Seller Jamie
  • 2011 BMW 1 Series
    117,000
    Mileage
    $9,995
    Price
    East Islip, NY 11730
    6.42 Miles Away
    car photo
    7
    Save
    Color: Black
    Private Seller Jamie
  • 2012 Honda Pilot
    149,488
    Mileage
    $14,995
    Price
    East Islip, NY 11730
    6.42 Miles Away
    car photo
    11
    Save
    Color: Gray
    Private Seller Jamie
  • 2018 Audi RS 5
    35,000
    Mileage
    $65,000
    Price
    East Islip, NY 11730
    6.42 Miles Away
    car photo
    16
    Save
    Color: Gray
    Private Seller Antonio
  • 2001 Chevrolet Suburban
    173,685
    Mileage
    $5,000
    Price
    West Islip, NY 11795
    7.37 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    51
    Score
    Good Deal
    Color: Other
    Owner Says:

    vehicle has 8100motor tow

    Private Seller Edward
  • 2003 Honda Pilot
    170,000
    Mileage
    $4,000
    Price
    West Islip, NY 11795
    7.37 Miles Away
    car photo
    2
    Save
    Color: Black
    Private Seller MARLENA
  • 2007 Ford Mustang
    18,000
    Mileage
    $35,000
    Price
    Islip Terrace, NY 11752
    7.99 Miles Away
    car photo
    11
    Save
    Color: Black
    Private Seller Andrew
  • 1971 Chevrolet Classic
    50,000
    Mileage
    $30,000
    Price
    Central Islip, NY 11722
    9.90 Miles Away
    car photo
    8
    Save
    Color: Blue
    Owner Says:

    1971 El Camino SS 396 motor Great floors great

    Private Seller Karen
  • 2003 Dodge Ram 1500
    102,884
    Mileage
    $8,500
    Price
    Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    10.08 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    60
    Score
    Great Deal
    Color: Blue
    Private Seller Zenon
  • 2014 Dodge Grand Caravan
    100,927
    Mileage
    $9,600
    Price
    Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    10.08 Miles Away
    car photo
    15
    Save
    Color: Blue
    Owner Says:

    New tires and new rims

    Private Seller LUIS
  • 2003 Ford Thunderbird
    24,000
    Mileage
    $19,000
    Price
    Lindenhurst, NY 11757
    10.08 Miles Away
    Vehicle Image Not Yet Available
    Save
    Color: Black
    Owner Says:

    Car is and has been garaged. Hardtop and stand

    Private Seller Bob
  • 2005 GMC Yukon XL
    446,810
    Mileage
    $9,500
    Price
    West Babylon, NY 11704
    10.45 Miles Away
    car photo
    24
    Save
    Color: Gray
    Private Seller Patrick
  • 2003 Jeep Liberty
    138,600
    Mileage
    $3,750
    Price
    Holbrook, NY 11741
    12.88 Miles Away
    car photo
    10
    Save
    80
    Score
    Best Deal
    Color: Black
    Owner Says:

    Jeep Liberty 2003 in good working condition. Great first car! Great station car.

    Private Seller Cindy
  • 2010 Lexus ES 350
    70,000
    Mileage
    $17,000
    Price
    Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    13.21 Miles Away
    car photo
    4
    Save
    10
    Score
    Poor Deal
    Color: Silver
    Owner Says:

    Mint condition paint Kept in Garage for life 25 oil changes , all highway

    Private Seller Kelly
  • 2012 Hyundai Accent
    40,000
    Mileage
    $13,000
    Price
    Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    13.21 Miles Away
    car photo
    6
    Save
    Color: Gray
    Owner Says:

    Car in excellent condition, very little use over the years. Recently had brake pads and rotors replaced within last

    Private Seller Andrew


Share Car Listings:

Cars for Sale by Owner in Near Cities

  • Sea Cliff NY
    2 New 193 Ads Save $495193 for Sale by Owner Listings. Save $495 with 56 Good, Great and Best Deals in Sea Cliff, NY.
  • Glen Cove NY
    2 New 189 Ads Save $518189 for Sale by Owner Listings. Save $518 with 55 Good, Great and Best Deals in Glen Cove, NY.
  • Glen Head NY
    2 New 187 Ads Save $503187 for Sale by Owner Listings. Save $503 with 53 Good, Great and Best Deals in Glen Head, NY.
  • Hempstead NY
    2 New 175 Ads Save $619175 for Sale by Owner Listings. Save $619 with 52 Good, Great and Best Deals in Hempstead, NY.